I guess the appropriate thing to say in this situation was not, in fact, “good game” but rather “YOU ARE ALL JUST TERRIBLE AT THIS GAME AND SHOULD GO BACK TO PLAYING VIVA PINATA.”
RMP = Random Male Player
Me: Good game.
RMP1: Fuck you, cunt.
RMP2: [screaming] SHUT THE FUCK UP IT WASN’T A FUCKIN’ GOOD GAME YOU FUCKIN’ SUCK.
RMP1: Yeah, you fuckin’ bitch ass cunt. Suck a dick. Suck a dick bitch.
RMP3: Little dingle-berry bitch.
RMP1: Suck a dick bitch.
RMP1: Jenny, suck a dick.